Share this on social media
Cop26 must urgently get specific on carbon removal in net-zero pathways
(Climate Home News, 4 Oct 2021) The latest report from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) emphasises that carbon dioxide removal (CDR) techniques will play a critical role in stabilising global temperatures.
Yet many of CDR’s limitations — be that technical, financial, or political — are overlooked in the report, which focuses on the physical science of climate change.
In its key scenarios, the report did not make clear exactly how much future CDR will be required. This will be the job of the IPCC Working Group III report currently due in March 2022 – too late for the Cop26 negotiations.
In scenarios where we limit warming to 1.5-2 degrees, large net removals are shown after 2050. But the actual levels of residual emissions and the CDR offsetting them are largely invisible to the reader.
This invisibility matters for two main reasons.
First, the lack of clarity conceals the huge technical and financial challenges that would be involved in delivering high levels of removals.
External link
Climate Home News, 4 Oct 2021: Cop26 must urgently get specific on carbon removal in net-zero pathwaysMore Related News
Carbon capture and storage (CCS)
12 Apr 2024: EU Parliament approves deal on world’s first carbon removal certification scheme
9 Apr 2024: Forest carbon accounting allows Guyana to stay net zero while pumping oil
2 Apr 2024: ExxonMobil accused of ‘greenwashing’ over carbon capture plan it failed to invest in
4 Mar 2024: France strikes CO2 storage deal with Denmark
1 Mar 2024: Germany to adopt 2060 target for net-negative greenhouse gas emissions
27 Feb 2024: Berlin launches ‘milestone’ strategies to capture and remove CO2 permanently
6 Feb 2024: Q&A: The EU industrial carbon management strategy
1 Feb 2024: German carbon capture row heightened by EU’s draft 2040 climate plan
30 Jan 2024: EU Commission wants captured CO2 to become ‘tradeable commodity’
19 Jan 2024: What to make of Europe’s upcoming carbon management strategy
11 Jan 2024: German industry joins forces with green groups on CO2 capture
12 Dec 2023: With Africa's carbon sinks up for grabs, offset debate heats up
11 Dec 2023: COP28: Can 'carbon capture' keep fossil fuels viable?
28 Nov 2023: German Greens make way for European carbon management plan
24 Nov 2023: EU tables new regulation to track climate threats to forests using satellites
14 Nov 2023: UK sued for counting wood burning with carbon capture as ‘negative emissions’
30 Oct 2023: Heavy industry turns to carbon capture to clean up its act
27 Oct 2023: ‘Carbon gamble’? EU lawmakers back CO2 removal certification scheme
26 Sep 2023: Green NGO supports controversial CCS to ensure e-fuels reach CO2 neutrality
21 Sep 2023: Industrial carbon capture: Only for truly ‘unavoidable emissions’
20 Jul 2023: Spanish EU Presidency draws criticism on carbon capture technology
7 Jul 2023: With EU blessing, Denmark aims to corner carbon capture market
12 Jun 2023: Carbon markets will not save our planet
26 May 2023: UN advises against offsets for carbon removal technologies
25 May 2023: ‘Worthless’: Chevron’s carbon offsets are mostly junk and some may harm, research says
12 May 2023: After court blocks renewables push, US promotes carbon capture & hydrogen
11 May 2023: Is 2023 the year when carbon capture and storage finally takes off?
9 May 2023: Nations split over fossil fuels and carbon capture
28 Apr 2023: Mitsubishi bets on carbon removal while keeping coal plants
21 Apr 2023: US carbon capture incentives leave EU ‘lagging behind’, biofuel makers warn
20 Apr 2023: Volcanic microbe eats CO2 ‘astonishingly quickly’, say scientists
4 Apr 2023: The Guardian view on carbon offsetting: an overhaul is overdue
24 Mar 2023: EU says ‘not banning carbon offsets’ in greenwashing crackdown
20 Mar 2023: EU sets world’s first target for underground CO2 storage capacity
13 Mar 2023: Sunak to focus on carbon capture and mini-nuclear reactors in energy policy
3 Mar 2023: Japan’s ‘green transformation’ would derail the energy transition in Asia
21 Feb 2023: Corporations push “insetting” as new offsetting but report claims it is even worse
10 Feb 2023: Denmark to put CO2 in seabed in step towards carbon negativity
27 Jan 2023: The Guardian view on carbon offsetting: a model with dangerous flaws
12 Jan 2023: Fossil fuel producers must be forced to ‘take back’ carbon, say scientists
23 Dec 2022: Carbon farming explained: the pros, the cons and the EU's plans
2 Dec 2022: EU Commission wants farmers, landowners to lead carbon removal push
25 Nov 2022: Could hemp be a key tool in fight against climate change?
22 Nov 2022: EU readies certification of carbon removals to help tackle climate change
15 Nov 2022: Deal reached on EU law regulating CO2 removals from forestry, land use
7 Nov 2022: Europe rapidly losing its forest carbon sink, study shows
28 Oct 2022: EU energy chief announces ‘strategic vision’ for CCUS in 2023
25 Jul 2022: EU could catch up with North America on carbon removal, experts say
5 Jul 2022: Payment for carbon farming: Towards an ambitious and pragmatic certification scheme
24 May 2022: Big tech’s growing embrace raises the stakes for CO2 removal
28 Apr 2022: Widespread carbon capture in Southeast Asia unviable without carbon pricing: report
22 Feb 2022: Europe aims to scale up infrastructure for permanent carbon removals
31 Jan 2022: Carbon offsetting is not warding off environmental collapse – it’s accelerating it
17 Dec 2021: Commission’s carbon farming ambition just buries the problem, stakeholders warn
16 Dec 2021: A sustainable carbons cycle or a vicious emissions cycle?
7 Dec 2021: Old UK oilwells could be turned into CO2 burial test sites
3 Dec 2021: A powerful and underappreciated ally in the climate crisis? Fungi
30 Nov 2021: EXPLAINER: What is 'net zero' and why does it matter?
4 Nov 2021: Forget net-zero: meet the small-nation, carbon-negative club
26 Oct 2021: Deforestation continues unabated ahead of COP26
17 Sep 2021: EU plans certification scheme for carbon dioxide removals
17 Sep 2021: EU plans certification scheme for carbon dioxide removals
10 Sep 2021: World’s largest plant capturing carbon from air starts in Iceland
27 Jul 2021: Indonesia to burn coal well into the 2050s, under updated climate plan
27 Jul 2021: Indonesia to burn coal well into the 2050s, under updated climate plan
4 Jun 2021: Bill Gates and EU pledge $1 billion boost for green technology
31 May 2021: Climate change: six priorities for pulling carbon out of the air
10 May 2021: Dutch govt grants $2.4 bln in subsidies to huge carbon storage project
4 Mar 2021: The climate crisis can't be solved by carbon accounting tricks
8 Feb 2021: Elon Musk puts up $100 mln for global carbon reduction competition
14 Jan 2021: Carbon capture and storage won’t work, critics say
14 Jan 2021: China pushes technical solutions in race to meet climate goals
14 Dec 2020: 10 myths about net zero targets and carbon offsetting, busted
29 Oct 2020: BP leads energy companies preparing two major UK carbon capture projects
23 Oct 2020: Official: EU taking first steps to bring forestry into carbon market
15 Oct 2020: Microsoft in deal with Equinor for Norway CO2 storage project
8 Oct 2020: Carbon capture 'moonshot' moves closer, as billions of dollars pour in
28 Sep 2020: Growing momentum behind carbon capture can make it a new clean energy success story
24 Sep 2020: What is carbon capture, usage and storage – and can it trap emissions?
22 Sep 2020: EU Commission defends 2030 climate target against ‘accounting trick’ critique
21 Sep 2020: Seas and forests are muddying the carbon budget
21 Sep 2020: Norway to spend $1.8 bln on world's first full-scale CCS chain
14 Sep 2020: EU commission accused of 'cheating' on net-zero emissions accounting
4 Sep 2020: World’s first ‘carbon-capture at sea’ set for shipping trials
9 Jun 2020: The hyping of negative emissions
28 May 2020: There is space for carbon storage underground
23 Apr 2020: Could Microsoft’s climate crisis ‘moonshot’ plan really work?
13 Mar 2020: Tropical forests may be heating Earth by 2035
6 Mar 2020: World can avoid catastrophic global warming with climate solutions in hand today – study
10 Feb 2020: Do you have it in green? The living fabrics that can help clean the air
Cop26
21 Dec 2021: How the Glasgow Dialogue can deliver finance for victims of the climate crisis
20 Dec 2021: Three ways the Glasgow joint declaration can accelerate US–China climate cooperation
13 Dec 2021: Who will be the judge of countries’ climate plans?
3 Dec 2021: Green business after COP26
2 Dec 2021: UK must ‘walk the talk’ on climate action, say official advisers
2 Dec 2021: Renewable energy has ‘another record year of growth’ says IEA
23 Nov 2021: The street and the boardroom are closer than they have ever been on climate
22 Nov 2021: Nigeria commits to annual carbon budgets to reach net zero under climate law
18 Nov 2021: ANALYSIS-Coal power stand at COP26 climate talks lends India time to transition
18 Nov 2021: Climate-vulnerable nations call for help forcing high emitters to act
16 Nov 2021: Deliver on EU's Cop26 promises? Quick phase out of fluorescent lighting can help
16 Nov 2021: Rights groups warn COP26 rules on carbon markets leave indigenous people exposed
16 Nov 2021: To defend fragile 1.5C goal, Glasgow Climate Pact must get results - fast
15 Nov 2021: Five big loopholes show COP 26 failing to curb fossil fuel extraction
15 Nov 2021: Empty words, no action: Cop26 has failed First Nations people
15 Nov 2021: Ratchets, phase-downs and a fragile agreement: how Cop26 played out
15 Nov 2021: India criticised over coal at Cop26 – but real villain was climate injustice
15 Nov 2021: ‘A step in the right direction’: EU reacts to COP26 deal
12 Nov 2021: Five EU countries form anti-nuclear alliance at COP26
12 Nov 2021: The promises and pitfalls of India’s plan for a global grid
11 Nov 2021: A space is opening to discuss oil and gas exit at Cop26. Lobbyists are pushing back
11 Nov 2021: US-China climate deal buoys COP26 summit - but not a 'turning point'
11 Nov 2021: Countries, cities, carmakers commit to end fossil-fuel vehicles by 2040
9 Nov 2021: Climate misinformation running high on Facebook, says report
8 Nov 2021: COP26 carbon-market talks 'difficult'—but hopes for breakthrough, says Norway minister
8 Nov 2021: Tuvalu minister stands in sea to film COP26 speech to show climate change
8 Nov 2021: From Chile and Taiwan via Glasgow, youth call for climate justice
8 Nov 2021: China calls for concrete action not distant targets in last week of Cop26
8 Nov 2021: Cop26 legitimacy questioned as groups excluded from crucial talks
8 Nov 2021: Focus turns to climate finance after flurry of COP26 pledges
5 Nov 2021: Canada, US, Italy among 20 countries to stop financing fossil fuels internationally
5 Nov 2021: India, Indonesia and Philippines join coal transition programme
5 Nov 2021: COP26 pledges could limit warming to 1.8C, says energy agency boss
4 Nov 2021: Cop26 will be derailed unless the rich world meets its obligation to the poor
4 Nov 2021: Beyond net zero by 2070: India’s new climate pledges explained
4 Nov 2021: ‘Put a price on carbon, nature cannot pay,’ EU’s von der Leyen tells COP26
2 Nov 2021: Optimism for Cop26: we must win the climate battle – and we absolutely can
2 Nov 2021: Over 100 global leaders pledge to end deforestation by 2030
2 Nov 2021: Nearly 90 countries join pact to slash planet-warming methane emissions
2 Nov 2021: India energizes COP 26 by pledging 50% renewables by 2030, net-zero emissions by 2070
2 Nov 2021: Indigenous peoples to get $1.7bn in recognition of role in protecting forests
2 Nov 2021: Vulnerable countries issue urgent calls to action as big emitters drag their heels
1 Nov 2021: Cop26: Biden urges action on climate change and vows US will ‘lead by example'
1 Nov 2021: How we as European climate envoys are backing action on adaptation finance
1 Nov 2021: Global climate talks open to cries of betrayal, blame
29 Oct 2021: Yes it’s expensive, but failing to meet climate challenge will cost a lot more
29 Oct 2021: Europe lays out battle plan for COP26 climate summit
29 Oct 2021: The make-or-break climate summit: here’s what’s at stake at Cop26
29 Oct 2021: China submits updated climate pledges to United Nations
28 Oct 2021: EU to launch COP26 project with South Africa to speed up coal exit
28 Oct 2021: Biden plan pledges ‘largest effort to combat climate change in US history’
27 Oct 2021: ‘Chess game’ as negotiators seek elusive carbon market deal at Cop26
27 Oct 2021: China issues plan to hit carbon emission peak before 2030
26 Oct 2021: Australia adopts target of net zero emissions by 2050 but won't legislate goal
26 Oct 2021: Saudi pledges net zero by 2060, but no oil exit plan
25 Oct 2021: China, India and Brazil must set out their plans to cut emissions
25 Oct 2021: What is COP26? This year’s critical climate talks, explained
25 Oct 2021: Key moments from decades of climate conferences
25 Oct 2021: Climate crisis: greenhouse gas levels hit new record despite lockdowns, UN reports
21 Oct 2021: Emerging economies slam Cop26 net zero push as ‘anti-equity’
21 Oct 2021: Russia says Putin won't fly to Glasgow, in blow for climate talks
21 Oct 2021: There are no real climate leaders yet – who will step up at Cop26?
18 Oct 2021: Climate change a double blow for oil-rich Mideast, experts say
18 Oct 2021: Cop26 corporate sponsors condemn climate summit as ‘mismanaged’
18 Oct 2021: Coal-state Democrat set to scupper Biden clean energy plans
14 Oct 2021: Heat rises on donor countries to meet overdue $100bn climate finance promise
12 Oct 2021: Cement makers across world pledge large cut in emissions by 2030
12 Oct 2021: World leaders urged to consider health benefits of climate action
11 Oct 2021: What is Cop26 and why does it matter? The complete guide
11 Oct 2021: Cop26: world poised for big leap forward on climate crisis, says John Kerry
8 Oct 2021: We need more, EU and U.S. urge China ahead of climate summit
7 Oct 2021: Can carbon's price finally match its value at COP26?
7 Oct 2021: EU to back five-year targets at COP26 climate talks
6 Oct 2021: Russia considering more ambitious climate targets
5 Oct 2021: Historical climate emissions reveal responsibility of big polluting nations
4 Oct 2021: Energy price crunch risks derailing UN climate talks, Iberdrola warns
4 Oct 2021: Pope, other religious leaders, issue pre-COP26 appeal on climate change
4 Oct 2021: UK seeks alliance to end public finance for coal, oil and gas projects overseas
1 Oct 2021: Comprehensive report makes climate change research accessible ahead of COP26
1 Oct 2021: Rich nations must commit more than $100 billion in climate fight, says India
30 Sep 2021: EU, Britain urge Russia to commit to net zero CO2 emissions
30 Sep 2021: Cutting methane should be a key Cop26 aim, research suggests
27 Sep 2021: Cop26: Women must be heard on climate, say rights groups
27 Sep 2021: Cop26 climate talks will not fulfil aims of Paris agreement, key players warn
23 Sep 2021: South Africa adopts more ambitious emissions target before climate summit
23 Sep 2021: EU countries struggle to agree approach to COP26 climate talks
21 Sep 2021: Climate crisis: history will judge failure to act, Johnson says at UN
20 Sep 2021: Global methane pledge offers hope on climate in lead up to Glasgow
20 Sep 2021: UK's COP26 chief says ball in China's court on making it a success
16 Sep 2021: Where is the money? Climate finance shortfall threatens global warming goals
16 Sep 2021: Climate experts fear Aukus will dash hopes of China emissions deal
16 Sep 2021: EU commits €4 billion more to climate vulnerables, calls on the US to step up
14 Sep 2021: As climate talks near, pressure grows on Asia to cancel new coal projects
10 Sep 2021: Cop26 will be ‘rich nations stitch-up’ if poorer countries kept away by Covid
9 Sep 2021: Scottish campaigners condemn Cop26 as ‘the most exclusionary ever’
7 Sep 2021: COP26 summit urged to prioritise adaptation as 'climate emergency' surge
6 Sep 2021: What is Cop26 and why does it matter? Your guide to the Glasgow climate summit
2 Sep 2021: Global South climate activists doubt COP26 participation over vaccine delay
2 Sep 2021: Global South climate activists doubt COP26 participation over vaccine delay
26 Aug 2021: Burning forests to make energy: EU and world grapple with biomass science
29 Jul 2021: South Africa proposes global goal for adaptation at pre-Cop26 ministerial
27 Jul 2021: Climate action must happen 'for our people, not to them', cities say
26 Jul 2021: K hosts 51 countries for climate talks ahead of COP26
22 Jul 2021: EU ministers discuss preparations for COP26 conference
22 Jul 2021: ANALYSIS - Push to 'keep 1.5 alive' heats up, 100 days from COP26 climate talks
20 Jul 2021: US seeks cooperation with China on climate but not at any price
15 Jul 2021: Move faster to cut emissions, developing world tells rich nations
5 Jul 2021: As COP26 draws closer, climate negotiations are still stuck on finance
25 Jun 2021: Success of climate change talks rests on finance, UN chief says
22 Jun 2021: UN blasts world leaders for failing to seal £72bn-a-year deal on climate
21 Jun 2021: Climate fund considers India, South Africa to pilot $2bn coal transition scheme
18 Jun 2021: Climate finance remains a stumbling block on way to COP26
17 Jun 2021: Ministers called in to break deadlock after unproductive climate talks
14 Jun 2021: G7 reaffirmed goals but failed to provide funds needed to reach them, experts say
8 Jun 2021: G7 leaders urged to show solidarity on climate change and COVID-19 at summit
1 Jun 2021: Europe calls for more ambitious climate policies ahead of COP26
24 May 2021: China must set out near-term policies to reach climate goals, says UK's Sharma
17 May 2021: Last hope over climate crisis requires end to coal, says Alok Sharma
17 May 2021: Half of emissions cuts will come from future tech, says John Kerry
10 May 2021: Tar sands executive named as Canadian ‘climate champion’ ahead of Cop26
27 Apr 2021: The Guardian view on Biden’s green revolution: it needs revolutionaries
13 Apr 2021: Greta Thunberg says she will not attend Cop26 climate summit
12 Apr 2021: Boris Johnson told to get grip of UK climate strategy before Cop26
8 Apr 2021: South Africa sets out to tighten 2030 emissions target
29 Mar 2021: UK urged to take lead in helping poor countries fund climate action
25 Mar 2021: A successful Cop26 is essential for Britain and the world. Here's how it can happen
9 Mar 2021: South Sudan plans to raise climate ambition amid ‘dire’ humanitarian crisis
9 Mar 2021: Britain lacks plan to meet climate target, watchdog says
8 Mar 2021: Brazil working with Biden on climate, Amazon deforestation, says foreign minister
4 Mar 2021: All aboard for COP26: 22 electric buses planned for Glasgow ahead of Climate Summit
1 Mar 2021: Sir David Attenborough tells UN ‘It is too late to avoid climate change’
22 Feb 2021: Keep funding green homes to meet emissions target, say businesses
8 Feb 2021: António Guterres calls for preparatory UN climate negotiations to be held online
4 Feb 2021: Cop26 dream team: The people setting the climate agenda on seven key issues
25 Jan 2021: Europe must become a global climate power
21 Jan 2021: Reformed trade rules can help to save the climate
18 Jan 2021: EU should set a joint and ambitious standard for climate finance
11 Jan 2021: IEA warns of post-pandemic emissions rebound
18 Dec 2020: Armed with proposals, young climate activists hunt decision-making power
15 Dec 2020: As Taiwan models net zero scenarios, campaigners push for 2050 target
11 Dec 2020: Celebs call for more women on UK's male-dominated UN climate summit team
3 Dec 2020: Oil and gas firms urged to work towards net zero British North Sea
3 Dec 2020: Pressure mounts on Britain to update its UN climate target
30 Nov 2020: Youth activists demand damages for climate victims at virtual ‘mock Cop26’
26 Nov 2020: UK aid budget cuts undermine trust ahead of Cop26 summit, experts warn
19 Nov 2020: Boris Johnson sets out 10-point plan to get UK on track for net zero
16 Nov 2020: Firms agree Scotland to England renewable energy 'superhighway'
12 Nov 2020: UK looks to Cop26 climate summit to fix awkward relationship with Biden
9 Nov 2020: ‘Hypocrites and greenwash’: Greta Thunberg blasts leaders over climate crisis
9 Nov 2020: As virus delays climate summit, youth 'Mock COP' takes (virtual) floor
5 Nov 2020: Emissions from energy sector likely to rebound from COVID-19, Capgemini warns
2 Nov 2020: Asian net zero wave leaves Australia’s Scott Morrison isolated
30 Oct 2020: UK negotiator: Countries must resolve carbon market dispute to step up ambition
8 Sep 2020: Major economies talk green recovery, hydrogen at Japanese summit
1 Sep 2020: Extra UN climate talks mooted for 2021 to help negotiators catch up
20 Aug 2020: Big oil need not apply: UK raises the bar for UN climate summit sponsorship
25 Jun 2020: No UN climate talks to be held in 2020, as interim meeting postponed again
25 Jun 2020: UK risks missing UN climate deadline, in headache for hosts of key summit
19 Jun 2020: Hopes for EU–China climate deal centre on a green recovery
8 Jun 2020: Delay to climate talks deepens uncertainty over future of carbon markets
8 Jun 2020: COVID-19 relief for fossil fuel industries risks green recovery plans
2 Jun 2020: Japan to launch ‘green recovery’ platform and ministerial meeting
1 Jun 2020: Covid-hit UK begins 18-month preparations for UN climate summit
29 May 2020: U.N. confirms year-long delay for crucial climate summit
28 May 2020: Next UN climate summit to be delayed to November 2021, UK hosts propose
2 Apr 2020: ‘We won’t slow down’ on climate: EU reacts to COP26 postponement
2 Apr 2020: 'We must use this time well': climate experts hopeful after Cop26 delay
2 Apr 2020: Cop26 climate talks postponed to 2021 amid coronavirus pandemic
19 Mar 2020: Coronavirus slows developing nations’ plans to step up climate action in 2020
6 Mar 2020: Legal gaps and US election could delay climate ambition before Glasgow summit
3 Mar 2020: African countries need rich nations to take the lead on ambition at Cop26
3 Mar 2020: Vital Cop26 climate talks could be derailed by coronavirus
28 Feb 2020: Net zero goal ‘greatest commercial opportunity of our time,’ says Mark Carney
25 Feb 2020: World faces ‘decisive decade’ to fix global warming, former UN climate chief says
18 Feb 2020: Investors urge Japan to strengthen climate targets ahead of U.N. summit
17 Feb 2020: UK government appoints Alok Sharma as Cop26 president
13 Feb 2020: UK climate diplomacy ‘already happening’ for Cop26 despite leadership vacuum
IPCC report
8 Dec 2023: We need power to prescribe climate policy, IPCC scientists say
3 Oct 2023: Slow route to net zero will worsen global climate crisis, IPCC chief warns
7 Apr 2022: Cities drive climate change, and can provide a solution, UN says
5 Apr 2022: Saudi Arabia dilutes fossil fuel phase out language with techno fixes in IPCC report
4 Apr 2022: Clean energy transition must be fast and fair, IPCC scientists say
4 Apr 2022: Final warning: what does the IPCC’s third report instalment say?
1 Mar 2022: Coastal cities seen unprepared as IPCC flags climate risk hotspots
1 Mar 2022: The IPCC climate report is grim – but there is still room for hope
1 Mar 2022: Revealed: How rich and at-risk nations fought over science of climate impacts
28 Feb 2022: IPCC issues ‘bleakest warning yet’ on impacts of climate breakdown
24 Feb 2022: As climate change wreaks havoc globally, IPCC report flags ways to adapt
2 Sep 2021: Leaked IPCC draft: Lifestyle change can cut double the emissions of Brazil by 2030
18 Feb 2020: 49% of world’s GDP now covered by net-zero targets, study says
9 Dec 2019: Time is ripe to align EU policies with Paris Climate Agreement
29 Aug 2019: Switzerland pledges climate neutrality by 2050
10 Dec 2018: Climate science on 1.5C erased at UN talks as US and Saudis step in
4 Dec 2018: To beat back climate change, the EU must help China – and itself
22 Nov 2018: Cities of the future: the ultimate design challenge
22 Nov 2018: Efficiency or economy? We can have both… or neither
6 Nov 2018: Houston, we have a problem . . .
15 Oct 2018: How will you respond to the IPCC’s urgent climate warning?
15 Oct 2018: There’s one key takeaway from last week’s IPCC report
15 Oct 2018: That $3 Trillion-a-Year Clean Energy Transformation? It’s Already Underway
