Share this on social media
I applaud Bristol for banning diesel vehicles. But why not ban all private cars?
(The Guardian, 4 Nov 2019) However welcome this plan is, the climate emergency demands truly radical steps.
West Country asthmatics breathed a deep sigh of relief last week, as Bristol city council unveiled long-awaited plans for a clean air zone in the city. The proposals would see a total daytime ban (from 7am to 3pm) on diesel vehicles entering a small central zone – a first in the UK, though increasingly common across the continent – plus a new charge for entering a wider area.
If approved tomorrow, the scheme will come into force in 2021. It cannot come too soon for Bristol’s most vulnerable residents: illegally poor air quality currently contributes to 333 annual premature deaths from respiratory illnesses in the city.
Preliminary results from a similar scheme in London, the ultra-low emission zone (ULEZ), are even better than expected, with toxic nitrogen dioxide (NO2) emissions down by nearly a third, demonstrating that this approach can really work. In one respect, Bristol’s plan goes one better, as its proposed scrappage scheme – financial compensation for ditching old diesel vehicles – includes an option, unlike London’s, to redeem value against an electric bicycle or on public transport.
But one curious feature of the plans exposes Bristol’s clean air zone as a microcosm of national policy paralysis, and demonstrates a collective failure of imagination on transport and the environment. The city intends to charge commercial diesel vehicles including buses for entering the wider clean air zone – while exempting private cars. They argue that charging private motorists would disproportionately affect low-income households that depend on their cars to get around, and in the absence of alternatives this is undoubtedly true.
External link
The Guardian, 4 Nov 2019: I applaud Bristol for banning diesel vehicles. But why not ban all private cars?
23 Jan 2023: German transport minister rejects autobahn speed limit after report shows climate benefits
20 Dec 2022: Toxic fumes are comin’: Truck pollution will double over Christmas
19 Dec 2022: Europe’s car industry must look to the future, not the past
21 Nov 2022: Black Friday exposes dark side of trucking
10 Nov 2022: EU Commission prioritises automaker profits in historic failure to reduce toxic pollution from cars and trucks
27 Oct 2022: Landmark deal for climate as EU agrees 2035 cut-off for polluting cars
29 Sep 2022: Carmakers’ global emissions 50% higher than reported
26 Aug 2022: California set to ban fossil fuel cars by 2035
15 Jul 2022: Parliament lawmakers raise e-fuels targets in bid to boost market
5 Jul 2022: EU deal on car CO2 standards leaves door ajar for e-fuels
29 Jun 2022: EU nations approve end to combustion engine sales by 2035
23 Jun 2022: EU’s 2035 ban on new thermal cars won’t spell the end of biofuels, industry says
17 Jun 2022: New EU standard must reduce vehicle pollution to lowest level feasible, say cities and civil society
10 Jun 2022: German car industry slams EU parliament’s 2035 ban on petrol, diesel cars
9 Jun 2022: EU Parliament passes ban on new petrol, diesel cars by 2035
19 May 2022: Most automakers fall short on climate goals: report
12 May 2022: Lawmakers back EU-wide ban on new fossil fuel cars from 2035, despite strong lobbying
18 Jan 2022: China car sector falling short of 'net zero' goals - Greenpeace
14 Jan 2022: Coal and trucks pushed US ‘further off track’ for climate targets in 2021
12 Jan 2022: US emissions roared back last year after pandemic drop, figures show
12 Jan 2022: Tough EU car emission rules ‘necessary’, says leader of key German state
15 Nov 2021: Major European carmakers will hit emissions targets too easily, research shows
16 Sep 2021: Oil and SUVs: Why Canada’s emissions have risen since Trudeau took office
9 Sep 2021: German industry gears up for its next lobbying battle: the internal combustion engine
7 Sep 2021: VW’s electric push ‘can’t go any faster’, says CEO
8 Jul 2021: EU fines VW and BMW £750m for colluding with Daimler on fumes
28 Jun 2021: Volkswagen to stop selling combustion engines in Europe by 2035
11 Jun 2021: Brussels promises new EU legislation for end-of-life vehicles in 2022
3 Jun 2021: Carmakers are killing our right to clean air
10 May 2021: Investors chide Toyota's Toyoda for questioning combustion car ban
7 May 2021: How low can you go? Volkswagen throws down the emissions gauntlet
19 Feb 2021: Australia risks being left behind in petrol-fuelled 'parallel world' as other countries embrace electric cars
4 Feb 2021: Virus lockdowns caused shift to ‘private mobility’: report
4 Feb 2021: Fleet electrification would cut road transport emissions by 50%, study finds
7 Dec 2020: Denmark agrees deal to have 775,000 electric cars by 2030
19 Nov 2020: FACTBOX - Fossil fuel-based vehicle bans across the world
16 Nov 2020: UK to ban sale of new petrol and diesel cars from 2030 - FT
12 Nov 2020: LEAK: Only zero-emission cars will win EU green investment label
12 Nov 2020: People plan to drive more post-Covid, climate poll shows
3 Nov 2020: Electric car sales set to treble, but there’s a risk of growth fizzling without tougher targets
4 Jun 2020: Transportation bill provisions are a first step for enabling lower-carbon transportation
25 May 2020: First Dieselgate ruling by Germany’s top court set to flag legal clarity
6 Apr 2020: Dieselgate motorists in search of compensation boosted by EU court
31 Mar 2020: Stakeholders call for ‘reality check’ on EU road transport and energy policy
30 Mar 2020: EU car lobby’s renewed attack on cars CO2 targets - on the back of COVID-19
10 Mar 2020: Exxon lobbyists urged Commission to tune down car CO2 rules
3 Mar 2020: Luxembourg becomes first country to make public transport free
6 Feb 2020: Four things the UK government must do to phase out petrol, diesel and hybrid cars by 2035
4 Feb 2020: Launching climate summit, UK plans to bring forward ban on new petrol and diesel cars
4 Feb 2020: Launching climate summit, UK plans to bring forward ban on new petrol and diesel cars
27 Jan 2020: Jeep, Suzuki models face EU ban for breaking emissions rules
23 Jan 2020: German raids over suspected Mitsubishi diesel fraud
12 Dec 2019: EU Green Deal to tune up car CO2 rules
8 Nov 2019: GM’s siding with Trump administration reveals a lack of commitment to clean, efficient vehicles
8 Nov 2019: High time we start taking renewable electricity seriously as a transport fuel
15 Feb 2019: Electric cars now cheaper than petrol or diesel alternatives, report finds
18 Dec 2018: EU agrees on 37.5% CO2 reduction for cars by 2030
27 Nov 2018: Germany’s emissions fiasco – time to get priorities straight
23 Aug 2018: Germany blocks ‘Dieselgate’ investigation in France
15 Mar 2018: Off-limit new diesel cars evade European city bans
15 Mar 2018: Dieselgate – 35 million manipulated cars on our streets and still no action
15 Mar 2018: UK car industry must pay up for toxic air 'catastrophe', super-inquiry finds
6 Mar 2018: The death of diesel: can struggling industry woo back consumers?
5 Mar 2018: Diesel slide continues as UK car sales fall for 11th month running
28 Feb 2018: German court rules cities can ban diesel cars to tackle pollution
27 Feb 2018: The great European fuel shift?
23 Feb 2018: German court delays ruling on city bans for heavily polluting diesel cars
15 Feb 2018: German cities to trial free public transport to cut pollution
11 Jan 2018: Synthetic fossil fuels: A dieselgate 2.0 in the making?
10 Oct 2017: Secrecy around air pollution controls in cars faces legal challenge
26 Sep 2017: Will new EU buildings law help pave the way for an electro-mobile future?
6 Apr 2017: Diesel vehicles will disappear sooner than expected, says EU industry chief
25 Jan 2017: Four trends that could clean up road transport
6 Jan 2017: Diesel cars are 10 times more toxic than trucks and buses, data shows