Revealed: Unpublished EU analysis is scathing of airline CO2 deal

(Transport and Environment, 18 Mar 2021) A global agreement designed to tackle airline emissions could actually undermine Europe’s climate efforts, according to an EU study obtained by Transport & Environment (T&E).

The Corsia deal, under which airlines can pay to offset growth of carbon pollution, is “unlikely to materially alter” the climate impact of air travel, it finds. T&E said the EU cannot rely on the ineffective UN offsetting scheme and should re-integrate into its carbon market (ETS) the emissions from flights entering and exiting Europe.

The EU ETS currently includes all flights within the European Economic Area but not flights in and out of the region. In June, the EU Commission, which has delayed publishing the analysis, will say how it thinks the UN agreement should apply to European flights.

The EU study finds:

  • Regulating EU airline pollution with Corsia alone is the worst option. “This option is associated with the biggest global net aviation CO2 emissions increase…” (p26)
  • Corsia “risks undermining the ability to reach net-zero emissions by mid-century” if it replaces existing EU climate regulations. (p17)
  • It’s questionable whether the carbon offsets actually deliver emissions reductions. “None” of the approved offsetting programmes meet all the required criteria. (p18)
  • At less than €1, carbon offsets will be too cheap to deter airlines from growing their emissions.[2] (p20). There is currently an excess supply of carbon offsets due to a weakening of the Corsia rules following industry lobbying last year, with three times as much supply than demand.
  • There is little chance of these issues being resolved. For example, the quality of offsets will not improve: “...the scope for delivering high quality credited emission reductions will decline.” (p48)

External link

Transport and Environment, 18 Mar 2021: Revealed: Unpublished EU analysis is scathing of airline CO2 deal

More Related News

The Corsia deal

8 Dec 2022: Lawmakers agree to restrict EU carbon tax to flights within Europe

Airline emissions

22 Apr 2024: Some UK airlines polluting more than ever as emissions approach pre-pandemic levels

19 Apr 2024: More than three quarters of European aviation emissions aren’t subject to a carbon price, new study shows.

12 Apr 2024: UK startup lifts lid on plan to turn human waste into jet fuel

22 Mar 2024: Europe’s transport sector set to make up almost half of the continent’s emissions in 2030

12 Mar 2024: KPMG & Accenture, GSK failing to keep up with industry leaders in cutting corporate travel emissions

5 Mar 2024: Will national teams become champions for sustainable travel during Euro 2024?

9 Feb 2024: The world is reducing its reliance on fossil fuels – except for in three key sectors

2 Feb 2024: Weatherwatch: study makes green case for electric planes

2 Feb 2024: Hanoi flights halted as city faces worsening air pollution

19 Dec 2023: Greenwashing cases against airlines in Europe, US

19 Dec 2023: Europe wins big on green fuels for planes and ships

EU emissions trading system ETS

23 Apr 2024: EU ETS2 for Buildings, Road Transport in 2027: why we need auctions to start early

18 Apr 2024: Carbon price fall deprives Europe's green funds of billions

15 Apr 2024: Germany must support other EU countries in preparing for social impacts of new CO2 price – env agency

9 Apr 2024: Carbon pricing crucial to deliver on greening transport, Volvo boss says

4 Apr 2024: Europe’s industry and power sector emissions plunge 15% in 2023

21 Mar 2024: Britain seeks views on 2027 carbon border tax

18 Mar 2024: How can biomass fulfil its potential in EU carbon markets?

15 Mar 2024: EU Carbon Prices are too low. But they should (and must) rise again

4 Mar 2024: Europe’s industrial decarbonisation at risk amid sharp drop in CO2 price

27 Feb 2024: EU carbon border levy could hurt Asian developing countries, yet do little to cut emissions: ADB

15 Feb 2024: Germany deletes EU CO2 allowances freed up by coal exit