Search eceee proceedings

What's the magic word? What we talk about when we talk about energy efficiency

Panel: 1. The dynamics of limiting (energy) consumption

This is a peer-reviewed paper.

Authors:
Jens Petter Johansen, NTNU Social Research, Norway
Jens Røyrvik, NTNU Social Research, Norway
Gudveig Gjøsund, NTNU Social Research, Norway

Abstract

Energy efficiency has become an integrated concept in modern language and public discourse, yet definitions and effects of energy efficiency and reduction is still an ongoing debate within academic discourse. This article investigate how industrial energy efficiency is framed and features in media narratives.

Media discourses both reflect and shape public opinion and essentially the political sphere, calling for an improved understanding of how energy efficiency features in public discourse. The paper is based on a media analysis of 309 articles featuring “industrial energy efficiency” in a selection of Norwegian newspapers in the period between 2013-2017.

We find numerous different framings of energy efficiency in the articles, where the authors draw on various notions of relative and absolute reduction in consumption, indicators and system boundaries. Even more common is the tendency to frame energy efficiency generically without explicit or implicit assumptions about reduction in consumption.

The analysis show that energy efficiency is rarely an object of contention or controversy and often not even the topic of the articles itself. Rather it figures in arguments within transition narratives of climate change mitigation and economic stability and growth.The paper outlines the underlying structures of how energy efficiency serves as a legitimizing concept in these narratives, as well as ammunition on both sides of heated controversies regarding development of renewable wind or hydro-parks, transmission lines and oil & gas industry.

The combination of a multitude of framings and generically use of the concept essentially lead to a black-boxing of the relationship between energy efficiency and reduction.Consequently, the associative equation between “energy efficiency” and “reduction” contributes to establish energy efficiency as a magic word in media narratives, suitable to legitimize almost every thinkable argument within transition narratives.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 1-332-19_Johansen_Presentation.pdf

Download this paper as pdf: 1-332-19_Johansen.pdf